Affordable Auto Insurance Companies After a DUI (2023)

Getting a DUI will cause car insurance premiums to go up. However, getting one or more DUIs doesn’t necessarily prevent getting car insurance. You might spend significantly less than you expected on cheap car insurance with a DUI – especially if you take the time to compare auto insurance quotes.

Today, an auto insurance company in the United States is more accepting of DUI-convicted drivers than others. No car insurance company will ever give you a discount for getting a DUI. Still, some of the biggest insurance companies in the US are known for offering competitive premiums regardless of whether this is your first, second, or even your third DUI.

Keep reading to learn more about how DUIs affect car insurance and to discover the best car insurance companies for drivers convicted of driving (DUI) or driving while intoxicated (DWI).

To compare auto insurance quotes from the top companies, enter your ZIP code into our free tool above.

State Farm

State Farm is one of the most DUI-friendly car insurance companies in the United States. Our research indicates that the average State Farm driver will pay just 15% to 25% higher insurance coverage premiums after a single DUI offense.

If you spend $100 per month on car insurance right now, your premiums might only rise to $115 or $125 per month after a single DUI charge. This is a significantly lower price hike than other major countrywide car insurance companies. Plus, if you are unsatisfied with the car insurance coverage, it’s quite easy to follow instructions on how to cancel State Farm insurance. Visit our State Farm auto insurance review for more information.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Progressive

Progressive is another car insurance company with a relatively friendly attitude towards DUI-convicted drivers. The average Progressive driver can pay approximately 30% to 40% higher car insurance premium after a single DUI conviction.

On an average policy, that might mean just a few hundred more dollars per year after your first conviction. This difference might seem large; however, considering other car insurance companies often double your premiums after a DUI, Progressive has a relatively lax attitude towards DUI convictions. You can read our Progressive auto insurance review for more information.

Farmers

Farmers insurance is another car insurance company known for maintaining low, competitively-priced premiums after a single DUI conviction. The average Farmers policyholder will see a 35% jump in insurance premiums after a first DUI conviction, which is significantly less than other providers on this list.

Allstate

Allstate policyholders can expect premiums to rise about 42% after the first DUI conviction. Allstate’s policies tend to be competitively priced across the country, although Allstate is rarely the cheapest provider in any region.

If you have a clean driving record, then Allstate might not be the cheapest option. However, Allstate may offer better cost savings for drivers with a DUI than any other insurance carrier on this list.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Geico

Geico offers competitively-priced car insurance product options across the United States. In many regions, Geico is the cheapest car insurance provider by hundreds of dollars per year. However, these low premiums come at a cost: as soon as you get a hit on your driving record, Geico will raise costs substantially.

A single DUI violation will raise your Geico car insurance coverage by anywhere from 50% to 60%, costing you hundreds of dollars more per year. That may sound bad. However, Geico’s premiums already start at a low level, which means you might still come out ahead of the other providers. Learn more about the company at our Geico auto insurance review.

Liberty Mutual

Some drivers report getting a good insurance rate with Liberty Mutual after a DUI, while others claim the company offers relatively high rates. Liberty Mutual will be the best option in certain states after a first DUI conviction, although it may not be the cheapest option in others. Consider requesting a quote with Liberty Mutual online today and read our Liberty Mutual auto insurance review to see what type of premium you can expect to pay.

Mercury Insurance

Mercury is one of the smaller major car insurance providers in the United States, although some drivers – particularly in California – claim they have received surprisingly low car insurance premiums after a single DUI conviction. If you have recently received a DUI in California or any other state, it may be worth requesting a quote from Mercury if you’re looking to get back on the road without breaking the bank.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

USAA

USAA is frequently chosen as one of the nation’s best car insurance providers. The only ‘catch’ is that you or an immediate family member needs to be active duty or a retired military member. If you qualify, USAA should provide competitively-priced car insurance premiums even if you have a DUI.

American Family Insurance

American Family is another major auto insurance company that offers competitive quotes to DUI drivers in certain states but not in others. In many states – including Illinois – American Family offers a surprisingly cheap car insurance quote to drivers who have been convicted of a DUI. Visit our American Family auto insurance review for more information.

Erie Insurance Group

Erie isn’t available nationwide. However, in states where Erie is available, the company may offer some of the cheapest car insurance policies in the region. Drivers in Ohio and Pennsylvania, for example, can pay surprisingly low insurance policy premiums with Erie even after a DUI conviction.

If you live in one of the 12 states covered by Erie and look for the best DUI car insurance, then Erie Insurance Group may be worth a look. The 12 states covered by Erie include Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and the District of Columbia. Check out our Erie auto insurance review to learn more.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Car Insurance Premiums for DUI Drivers Vary Widely Across the Country

The best car insurance company for a driver with a DUI in California will be different from the best insurer in Georgia or North Carolina.

Car insurance laws vary widely by state. DUI punishments can also vary according to the severity of your crime. Some states and insurance companies treat drunk driving convictions very seriously, while others let you get one or two DUIs without impacting insurance premiums.

An auto insurance rate can also vary widely based on your age. A 55-year-old driver with a clean driving record who received her first DUI, for example, may face less punishment than a 22-year-old driver who just received his second DUI.

We recommend comparing quotes online today to find the best car insurance company based on your unique situation. No two car insurance policyholders are alike.

Final Word

Driving under the influence (DUI) or driving while intoxicated (DWI) are serious convictions. You can expect to pay 30% to 150% higher insurance premiums after a DUI conviction.

However, by requesting quotes from the insurance companies listed above, you can limit the impact of your DUI and ensure you continue paying competitive rates for car insurance after your DUI.

If you want to switch insurance companies, on the other hand, you should do it quicker (start looking now). If you would like to compare quotes from other companies, enter your ZIP code into our free tool.

Compare over 200 auto insurance companies at once!

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption